Top QB Rookies

Rank
Player
Team
Comments

1
Ben Roethlisberger
PIT
Consistency is his top selling point. As a rookie, he made the game look very easy, a la Tom Brady.

2
Eli Manning
NYG
Seemed overwhelmed early in the year, but finished strong, including a big come from behind victory.

3
Luke McCown
TB
Wasn’t afraid to put the ball in the air, 4 TDs and 7 INTs in merely 5 games. Good or bad, that’s a lot of action.

4
Matt Schaub
ATL
Looked shaky during the few times he played; nothing new for a first year QB.

5
Philip Rivers
SD
We’re still waiting too see what this kid is all about, Drew Brees took all of his air time.

6
J.P. Losman
BUF
Very limited action, he was behind Bledsoe at the time.

7
Jim Sorgi
IND
Peyton Manning broke the TD record this year. Sorry Sorgi, your time is still to (never) come.